HPB Mins 10/24/2007HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD
REGULAR MEETING
MINUTES
4:00 p.m. -Wednesday
City Council Chambers
OCTOBER 24, 2007
CALL TO ORDER
Chair Hernandez called the Historic Preservation Board meeting of Wednesday,
October 24, 2007 to order at 4:10 p.m. in the City Council Chambers, located at 70
North First Street, Campbell, California, and the following proceedings were had to wit.
ROLL CALL
Board Members Present:
JoElle Hernandez, Chair
Susan Blake, Vice Chair
Julie Heinzler
Micky Lutz
Board Members Absent:
Joanna Herz
Staff Members Present:
Jackie C. Young Lind, AICP, Acting Community Development Director
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
Vice Chair Blake made a motion to approve of the Regular Meeting Minutes of
September 26, 2007. Board Member Lutz seconded. Approved 4/0.
Vice-Chair Blake made a motion to approve Special Session Minutes October 10, 2007.
Board Member Lutz seconded. Approved 3/0.
ORAL REQUESTS
1. Update on the proposed addition to a residence owned by Mr. Michael Navone that
is located within the Alice Avenue Historic District at 235 South First Street.
Michael Navone stated that his plans have been submitted to Building. Mr. Navone
stated that it was discovered that the existing foundation is not reinforced, and
Historic Preservation Board -Regular Meeting Minutes
October 24, 2007
Paae 2 of 3
showed photos of this. Mr. Navone discussed three possible solutions: 1) lift the
existing 20' x 20' home and construct a foundation, then remove the remaining rear
and right side walls to accommodate the addition plan, 2) save the front and right
side framing only, or 3) rebuild the entire home. Acting CDD visited the property
earlier today. Mr. Navone indicated that he will duplicate the eave vents, rafter
brackets, stipple stucco texture, window trim (2x4 sill with double stucco stop) and
double hung windows on the new addition. Chair Hernandez thanked Mr. Navone
for the update. No action was taken as this was heard under oral request. Chair
Hernandez stated that a special meeting could be held before the Regular Meeting
of November 28, 2007, if needed. Mr. Navone will continue to work on his plans for
the foundation replacement.
NEW BUSINESS
1. Review of a proposal for the relocation and placement of asingle-family residence
on property located at 109 S. Fourth Street and owned by John Peters.
Associate Planner Haley presented the staff report. Chair Hernandez asked about
the significance of the existing house at the front of the site slated for demolition.
Associate Planner Haley stated that the front house is not historically significant and
has not been well maintained. Vice Chair Blake stated that the Historic Preservation
Board had approved the relocation of the historic home setting at the rear of the
subject property some time ago and she is very pleased that this home is finally
being restored. This home is on the Walking Tour Brochure. It is a beautiful home
and has been protected. Chair Hernandez asked if the doors and windows will be
maintained. Associate Planner Haley answered yes. Board Member Heinzler made
a motion to approve. Vice Chair Blake seconded. Passed 4/0.
OLD BUSINESS
1. Historic Resource Inventory: Submit proof-reading all new HRI sheets on November
28, 2007.
2. Historic Preservation Code: Study Session to be held November 28, 2007. Please
review materials from August 22, 2007 before the November meeting and bring
comments.
3. Update on a proposal by Pino Spanu (Campbell Cafe) for exterior paint colors to
Second Bank of Campbell Building located at 360 East Campbell Avenue owned
by Ms. Karen Blancato: Vice Chair Blake contacted two sources to discuss possible
recommendations for the wainscot cap issue. Vice Chair Blake's sources
recommended repair techniques. Chair Hernandez also contacted a preservation
source who recommended repair as the most cost effective option.
Historic Preservation Board -Regular Meeting Minutes
October 24, 2007
Page 3 of 3
ANNOUNCEMENTS/COMMUNICATIONS
Governor's Award: Historic Design Guidelines for Residential Buildings received the
Governor's Award. Awards ceremony in Sacramento to be held on November 16,
2007, 1-4 p.m. Jeanette Watson, Chair Hernandez, Vice Chair Blake and Acting
CDD Young Lind will attend.
2. Michi Sushi: Jane attended to observe on behalf of Mr. Shin, owner of Michi Sushi
ADJOURNMENT
The Historic Preservation Board was adjourned at 4:45 p.m. to the next Regular
Meeting scheduled for 4:00 p.m. on Wednesday, November 28, 2007. A Study Session
will immediately follow the Regular Meeting on Wednesday, November 28, 2007.
PREPARED BY:
ie C. ng L , AIC ,
Acting Community Development Director
i
APPROVED BY: - ~ %Z~c~2~i~-~
JoE e Hernandez, Chair