HPB Review of Remodel-1984
HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD
AUGUST 22,1984
BUSINESS'
Review of proposed' plans to remodel structures
located on property known as 30 S. Central Avenue
Mr. Haley reviewed the proposed plans to remodel'~;structures'., oti¡;g~thât "
proposed I11Òdif¡icationsincl ude changing theTcorrugated metal iding",:to wood
siding, the introduction of windows, the prov:ision of handica ped and'¡stairway ~
access to the building. the use of 3 floorsin\the building"f r primarily
retail/office use, and the retention of the;;r.us,ted:corrugated metal:'troof,.'
Mr. Haley added that the rating on the currentJtiíwentory,:1ist<for,xthesé:>,',
structures is 89.5. " ,,7 , ">,,.,
3D S. Central Ave.
.
1
t'
, "
Ms. Co~ts stated,ttiat Campbell has very few,~r~Jnin~{,str,Hçi~~~:~'g~;t'~~'::A~~~~+;,,:,..j,
hi storl ca 1 ' nature. and a 1 thou~h these struc~ur;esyare~;J1<?t~tp;~r:t ~ulè1')~,y¡'a~~~~ic~11Y
pleasing, they do have a quallty representi~g'}.the Cann1ngln~ stry.The:~)/" '
i ntroducti on of wi ndows will destroy::thi s'lqûàli ty. -She as ked:~' f",there.: '
might be some other way to get light into the building so tha :the'exterior
could remain as it looks now.
, ,
Mr. Bob Bonnett tndicated that skylights would destroythe'ró fl.ine';'and,the
industrial feeling. He noted that the introduction of windo swouldrnot,
be significant. Mr. Bonnett continued that the reason for<ch nging~¡¡from
the metal siding to wood siding is for weatherjngp~ofingan¡h~~~¡-ttr~nsfer:.
, '~;~!;,; ,'> , ':,::t:' :t{!:' ,¡~!,,;¡!:-l;'; "",', ,
','"""""""",<",-"""",t:,,' "" ""? ,':," :,",',,',",I,ðil,l,',¡";.':'"Ih,,,',;i..,1H,\.:,~,.,~,.Wšl,,':,,',',.,,'\,,:',',,¥,'.¡,f¡¡~""';":',"""",'>'.,",~.",',(~'','",,',',',,:,:;r ¡;~" , ,
~ :rJ""", I'¡"";I"', ,;:;t';'1~¡";YIPd th~i hi~,' ':!]:J¡."","$"'JI.:Ajl,,"',:)It"vr:n ". ',,',',' """"""':"""'."""",,',~,:,>,',"~",:,~,So,:\;;4,:..~",.~'1,;_" ,
-rn~t...:.". '.: :'~":~>4""~'X;~,ir;:':'i,.,..¡;J:..""",:" . ,,~, "'-
~.
,," .
I¡
~
.
-2-
Boardmember Hebard indicated that he did not have a problem with the intro-
duction of windows; however, he would like to see the retention of the metal
siding where it currently exists.
Mr. Stan Davis, property owner, noted that the majority of the building is
wood siding at present; and, continued that the problem with the metal
siding is that potential tenants do not like the looks of it.
Boardmember Chivers stated that his feelings on this particular~roperty
are that it has been an eyesore for many years and he has always wished
someone would do something about it. He felt that it was not good for
the downtown area to have this building setting there, and stated that
the developer should be given approval to go ahead with his plans.
Boardmember Burns stated his agreement with Boardmember Chivers.
Boardmember Hebard stated that he felt much the same way; however, he
. -noted his concern for the change in appearance in the building in that
this building:has not been changed very often (unlike the Factory) and
retains a great deal of its original looks. Boardmember Hebard con-
tinued that he was not sure if the retention of this building was for
historic preservation, or {or nostalgia. Even if the appearance is
changed, as proposed, it will still be of historic significance to
Campbell; and,~perhaþs some of the preservation desires would have to
be set aside in order to have the building around longer, although he
would like to see the metal siding remain.
MIS:
Burns, Chivers
- That the Historic Preservation Board recommend
approval of the presented plans for remodeling of
structures on property known as 30 S. Central Ave.,
and forward these recommendations to the Planning
Commission. Motion carried unanimously (4-0-1).
* * *
~
-' Itt No. 4A
STAFF CCM-ffiNT SHEET - HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEETING OF AUGUST 23, 1984
30 S. Central Ave. - Review of proposed plans to reIOOdel st tures located
on property known as 30 S. Central Aven e.
STAFF REOJM-1ENDATION
That the Board review the presented plans for remodeling of troctures on
30 S. Central Avenue (currently Zapp' s) and forward any reco endations to
the Plarming CoITØIlission.
DIsæSSION
The applicant has presented plans to remodel the property at 30 S. Central
Avenue (fonnerly the Bodega, originally the S. C. Valley Fro't Growers
Assn. building, currently Zapp' s).
Changes to the existing building include:
1.
2.
Changing the corrugated metal siding to wood siding.
The introduction of windows.
3. The provision of handicapped and sta irway access to he
building.
4. Use of 3 floors in the building for primarily retail office use.
5. Proposal' of a color scheme.
6.
The retention of the rusted corrugated metal roof.
Attached for the Board's review is a copy of the Historic Re ources Inventory
fonn. It should be noted that this structure carries a rat g of 89.5 on
the current Inventory List.
Staff is recommending that the Board cons ider the plans pres nted, and make
any recoITØIlendations it deems appropriate to the Planning C ission.
* * *