The URL can be used to link to this page

HPB 90-03, ZC 90-05 (2)CITY OF 76 ALICE AVENUE HPB 90-03/ 1/1 CAMPBELL ZC 90-0 5 76 Alice Avenue IIPB 90-03/ Maxwell, G. 'LC 90-05 1 i Mr. and Mrs. George Maxwell 76 Alice Avenue Campbell, CA 95008 378-5236 1 o o 7 4 h :J 7 J > J 4 v u 3 x ORDINANCE NO. 1809 BEING AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF CAMPBELL APPROVING A HISTORIC LANDMARK DESIGNATION FOR THE RESIDENCE AND PROPERTY KNOWN AS 76 ALICE AVENUE IN AN R-1-H (SINGLE FAMILY RESI- DENT�AL/HISTORIC OVERLAY) ZONING DISTRICT. APPLICATION OF MR. AND MRS. GEORGE MAXWELL, HPB 90-03. The City Council of the City of Campbell does ordain as follows: SECTION ONE: That the City of Campbell hereby designates the residence and property known as 76 Alice Avenue in an R-1-H (single Family Residential/Historic Overlay) Zoning District, as an Historic Landmark, as per the application of Mr. and Mrs. George Maxwell. SECTION TWO: This Ordinance shall become effective thirty days following its passage and adoption, and shall be published once within fifteen days upon passage and adoption in the San Jose Mercury News, a newspaper of general circulation in the City of Campbell, County of Santa Clara. PASSED AND ADOPTED this 4th day of September, 1990 by the followinq roll call vote: AYES: Councilmembers: Kotowski, Watson, Conant, Burr, Ashworth NOES: Councilmembers: None ABSENT: Councilmembers: None APPROVED: • ��/.rT.! ''JOIN J. ASHWORTH, MAYOR ATTEST: /Z/,i ( --1 -at �• BARBARA OLSASKY, CITY CLERK CITY OF CAMPBELL 70 NORTH F I R S T S T R E E T CAMPBELL• CALIFORNIA 95008 (408)866-2100 Department: CITY CLERK September 5, 1990 George and Dorothy Maxwell 76 Alice Ave. Campbell, CA 95008 Dear Mr. and Mrs. Maxwell: The City Council at its regular meeting on September 4, 1990 gave second reading to Ordinance No. 1809 approving a Historic Landtark L::signation for property located at 76 Alice Avenue. Enclosed is a copy of Ordinance No. 1809 for your records. If you should have any questions regarding the City Council's action concerning this matter, please contact either this office or the City Planning Department. Sincerely, Barbara Olsasky City Clerk Encl . cc: Planning Dept. SEP 6149U 1 CONS— Q7T CALENDAR /J;�ll�/" 7Ta Mayor requested 1f any �s�bsr of the Co�11 consra being of 1n the audlsnce wished ��, to ras»w an free frog Consent Calendar vas ldareda�i Giendar. The 9 / J follows: none, the 2. Hlatoric D88 4-n4Cioni Ordnance No. 1809 - ZC 90-05/HPO 90.3 - 76 Alic• eve. - of SecondRR1adin1, od Ordinance ly R 1809 atialZoning ves desisnetlon of 76 Alice Ave in an (, 1 1• F /Historic Overlay) � District. Ah Alk CITY COUNCIL MINUTES OF AU3UST 7, 1990 - 19. Public Mowing - Introduction of Ordinance -f2C 90-05/'MPH 90-3 - 76 &We Aw was - Historic Designation 1' This is the time and place for a public hearing to consider approval of an Historic Landmark designation for the subject property. Planning Director Piasecki - Staff Summary Report dated 8/7/90 The Mayor declared the public hearing opened. n,ere being no public discussion regarding this issue, M/S: Watson/Burr - to close the public hearing. Motl.on aoopced unanimously. MIS: Watson/Conan[ - to approve dne pagaclve Declaration which has bean prepered for this application. Motion adoptad unanimously. HIS: Watson/Cceiant - to introduce -or first reading Ordinance 1809 approving a Historic Landmark Designation for property known as 76 Alice Avenue. Motion adopted by the following roll call vote: APES: Comcllmembers: Watson, Conant, Burr, Watson NOES: CounciLsamb.-s: None ABSENT: Council'embtrs: Iotovski The City Clerk read the ordinance title. MIS: Burr/Watson - to valve fur let reading. Notion adopted unanimously. CITY OF CAMPBELL - COUNCIL REPORT Meeting Gate: August 7, 1990 helm Category: PUBLIC HEARINGS AND INTRODUCTION OF ORDINANCES Initiating Dept: Pla wing Title: Public Hearing - ZC 90-05/HPB 90-3 - 76 Alice Avenue - Historic Designation PLANNING COMMISSION RECOMMENUATION The Plannitg Commission recommends that the City Council take the following actions: 1. Approve the Negative Declaration that has been prepared for this appl—ation. 2. Designate the property located at 76 Alice Avenue as an Historic Landmark. The subject property is located in the Alice Avenue Historic Overl-.ry Zoning District that was established by the City Council in March, 1987. At this time the owners of the property are requesting that an Historic Landmark" designation be approved for their home which was built in the early 1920's. (See attached Historic Resources Inventory). ZONING AND GENERAL PLAN CONSISTENCY The proposed Historic Landmark designation is consistent with the R-1-H (Single Family Residential/Historic Overlay) Zoning District, and with the Land Use Element of the General Plan which designates "Low Density Residential" land use for the site. MAJOR ISSUES None. Planning Commission and Historic preservation Board Actions: On May 23, 1990, the Historic Preservation Board adopted Resolution No. 22 by a 5-o-0 vote recommending that the Planning Commission and the city Council take the necessary actions to designate this property as an Historic Landmark. i / 7) Approved by Department Head Approved by City Manager page 2 Council Report 2C 90-05 On July, 10, 1990, the Planning Commission adopted Resolution No. 2682 by a 6-0-1 vote, Commissioner Wilkinson being aL-ent, recommending that the that the City Council designate the property as an Historic Landmark. attachments: 1. Resolutions No. 2682 and Resolution 22 2. Applicbtion and supporting documentation for Landmark, Designation 3. Staff Report to the Planning Commission dated July 10, 1990 4. Planning Commission Draft Minutes of July 10, 1990 AdL RESOLUTION NO. 2682 PLANNING COMMISSION BEING A RESOLUTION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF CAMPBELL RECOMMENDING DESIGNATION OF THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT 76 ALICE AVENUE AS AN HISTORIC LANDMARK ZC 90-05/HPB 90-03) After notification and Public Hearing as specified by law on the application filed by Mr. and Mrs. George Maxwell for designation of their residential property at 76 Alice Avenue, in an R-1-H (Single -Family Residential/Historic overly) Zoning District, as an Historic Landmark in the City of Campbell, and after testimony by proponents and opponents the hearing was closed. After due consideration of all evidence presented, the Planning Commission did find as follows: 1. This residential structure is representative of the historic character of the Alice Avenue Historic District. 2. The 1)uilding is in good condition and has not been altered significantly. 3• Designation of this structure as a landmark will emphasize the importance of the Alice Avenue Historic District to the Community. Based upon the above findings, the Planning Commission of the City of Campbell does hereby recommend that the City Council take action to designate the property at 76 Alice Avenue, Campbell, California, as an Historic Landmark. PASSED AND ADOPTED this 10th day of August 1990, call vote: by the following roll AYES: Commissioners: Christ, Fox, Alne, Meyer, Olszewski, Perrine NOES: Commissioners: None ABSENT: Commissioners: Wilkinson APPROVED: Jay-E. Perrine Chairman ATTEST: Steve T. Piasecki Secretary Salt 00fie filercurm duos 750 RIDDER PARK DRIVE SAN JOSE, CALIFORNIA 95190 IN THE OF CAMPBELL .«._«..».......__. .CITY »._...._...._...»........ _............................ STATE OF CALIFORNIA COUNTY OF SANTA CLARA O/ (- �ampie�� Clt of Cam bell NOTICE OF NEARING 75 North Central Avenue ......«...«.......«..»..........«...«_».............»._«...................««. ••••_••«•• NoncE a NEAFer GNEN nw W c*, code a ti a a.ce.• tr4 •w Cam bell CA 95G08 .«.......«...e.........L....«.._.........».......................«......«.._....»_............ FY IIOI• apaw, d •ndM FI.I..tI�, w•s�y Ayl,a 7. 1.m b M G.V N•.TCana Q+11Ow► fi M Fa A g.wt r.l w.1 oft- NOTICE OF NEARING � """' .Oft tia, •2ar+Cllrly. _................_._....«......_..__..».......» NO............ ». ..._....................__.__.._....... •. w 1 r 7� we. �.w. ti tM ay a G^lo.a. F.ND. iL b6a STATE OF CALIFORNIA, COUNTY OF SANTA CLARA > ss. A N"w.D an t. a_6.w1 a.or.• ',,.,;,ate• ,+■+w. "p".p"��•1^1^r1�+ ^ �+ +a "+a ..l Cam Z n•Itn F.•t 1... Gwp •R�N� rn...wray+y e••q ft M' — -a—ot• lino YnTh . al .l .. I.nY 11w..Ynw nwoow alloy. «n an. ti tAt.M bl.l.x ear W " a .0— y ran, lino Iw .poly to Iv Mw.u.0 II1M M'.d+ 111� Ilgl..l •rl. a �++ a ..+ N..,•y F•.•.• •0`*+.nYlae p..ca.Arys: w w.:,:Z. aa.l0 Y YW I..ra .M al• . Iti w..cD+ CM. a W p.nw .n0 owbnw a al• s.. JOY m cla, . •+.•'.P.pw a o.....1 c.lwltn P—W .n pu..al+C •Yy ., W cM to S.n JOY n a •0..•C aw " yO1 alYill7. lll. IY... a 6w °•r a rl.w •.m co oy a Sw•s Ova, slaw a Ca.lda . In.l saw 6Y Jw. aaa cwy was la lino .as •1 Y I.na. `-- ,n — . nw•n — a l .l tlrculalm ., WI loam Y aw rle..� .omY,Y.Itr IwaN a a_ ft "— W S— 6000 va le.w.q a W G—` Coe. a Iti Slw1 a f�sldn.. wN... MwWO M Yi1 aKltn•. b d,YwvC W b.dbe 11.a N..... am.sppn..,ta •..a.l.• b M Gyy a r+nlpnM p.Mr tMKlw. n...p • tw.v •a .Wadlp11d1 YI a pN"0 wp.a bwa. •np Y nd bwlep In In. Mwlw. v puW.lup b IM .nwl•M.vd v .+I,I,cla a . tl.nldYr a.Y, ddYYm.l Ir.b, wary, ,.0 d awr.mvrl� Id aY Qrn a plea t „y q+� NMM1y Q,••6p,1• •b �M d W .dwl..rrrl .M ..I.uat.n a a,y runEr a aual d•a..., pa..t.wt, Ir.b.. G..wa, bnonJrl.l..vn; W I al lit Ian.. GaV�.h a M M� 6Y•I M)b Nb•I.'^•p.pr Ira tMw. Yw.•.II.Q pMW an0 pOd.iv. In IM W J coy a IM. ,..1l1yop1 Tmalt rprw.Y Srob Nas.,wpR.ba.p Jw.O.YMa.Y/ QpTWY mwl. t Wnr rowrlpa—rafv.,aW w.ndln wnd w,vI.l.loM.n.. IpMnwid4I— a.. d..c—v .M ..aYaeq n 0w1«mM l—rlal.W I.rnN nm 'x$ LL &AAa AAA aKV YIa•lMI.dtww .tlMa ro+I.SM aI.. •rla.d to 0. plwtiWaa MnmcqW a..-"rw ..................Ju1X»?11.1222........................................................................ Dr" 0 f.n A.Y. C..tda. 30th July 90 �r.._.._._....___.__....__._.......a.y a......_..............._............................m............_....... i slier. Yle. F•l++r a vr1•r WI th b•vo•q . Inw and ml.Cl. , ►I•+W e+n a W.................................. pm, wl+.nw a In. sn Ju• .Iwedy NwM. PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES OF JULY 10, 199(k, �AGEIl OF 1 CRY of PLANNING Dfr.:n mfw 4. ZC 90-05 Public Hearing to consider the City -initiated (HPB 90-03) Zone Change to designate property at 76 Alice Avenue, as an Historic Landmark in the City of Campbell. APN: 413-04-061. Chairperson Perrine read the Application into the record. Staff Presentation: Gloria Sciara, Planner I, presented the Staff Report noting the staff recommendation to adopt a resolution approving the Historic Landmark designation and Zone Change. Commissioner Alne asked staff to explain the process relating to Historic Landmark designation. Ms. Sciara explained that the Applicant applied to the Historic Preservation Board for the designation and then the City has to initiate the Zone Change. The Public Hearing on ZC 90-05 was opened. Public Comment: There were no public comments. MIS: Fox, Olszewski MOTIOK To CLOSE THE PUBLIC HEARING WAS UNANIMOUSLY APPROVED. Commissioner Christ asked if the barn, also located on the property would be part of the Historic Designation. In response Ms. Sciara stated that she felt it would be included as an accessory structure. HIS: Meyer, Olszewski NOTION TO ADOPT RESOLUTION NO. 2682 APPROVING ZC 90-05 PER STAFF RECOMMENDATION, ACCEPTING THE NEGATIVE DECLARATION AND ZONE CHANGE THE WAS UNANIMOUSLY APPROVED BY THE FOLLOWING ROLL CALL VOTE: AYES: Cotiissioners: Christ, Fox, Alne, Meyer, Olszewski, Perrin NOES: Cooissioners: None. ABSENT: Commissioners: Wilkinson t- o py ►r cimy a TMENT PIANNiN- UEVAk ITEM NO. 4 STAFF REPORT - PLANNING COMMISSION MEBTING OF JOLX 10, 1990 ZC 90-05 Public Hearing to consider the a City -initiated (F?B 90-03) Zone Change to designate property located at City -initiated 76 Alice Avenue, as an Historic Landmark in an R-1-6 (Single -Family Residential/Historic Overlay) Zoning District. APN: 413-04-061. STAFF UZVKKMM&TjM That the Planning Commission take the following actions: 1. ACCEPT a Negative Declaration. ADOPT A RESOLOTION, incorporating the attached findings, approving the Zone Change and designate this property as an Historic Landmark. APPLICANT'S PROPOSAL The property owners of the residential property located at 76 Alice Avenue has requested designation of their home as a Historic Landmark under the Historic Landmark provisions of the Historic Preservation Ordinance. ERQD T DATA Parcel Area: Gross Acres: .30 Net Acres: .25 GENSRar PLAN AND ZONING CONSISTENCY A. Zoning Designation: The site is designated for R-1-H (Single -Family Residential/Historic Overlay) Zoning District. This Historic District was created by the City Council on March 3, 1987, to help preserve the character of the Alice Avenue neighborhr,od. B. General Plan Designation: The site is designated Low -Density Residential, less than 6 units per gross acre. The proposal is consistent with the General Plan and is developed at 3 units per gross acre. Historic Landma k Dea' *' The requested Historic Landmark imposes additional review procedures for demolition permits and architectural alterations. 2•C 90-05 76 Alice Avenue PC Mtg: 7-10-90 page two ARQUI. SIGNIFICAvCB: The architectural style can be categorized as Provincial Period Revival c. 1920-41) and is one-story wood framed house finished with stucco, wood shingled hipped roof, with a front gable. The exterior treatment consists of triple case -type windows with square pane glass in the front gable and three rectangular sash hung windows in the northwest front facade. HISTORIC SIGNIFICANCE: The residence was constructed in approximately 1922 and owned by Mr. George E. Hyde, owner of a canning and fruit dehydrating plant, in Campbell. Alice Avenue was created in 1915 on a portion of the site of the fruit drying yards owned by the Hyde Company. The residential subdivision was called the Hyde Residential Park after George and Alice Hyde. The property was later owned by Mr. Lee Saunders an early weightmaster and receiving foreman for the J. C. Ainsley Company. In 1958, the property was acquired by Mr. George Maxwell. Mr. Maxwell was the first full-time Fire Chief for the City of Campbell and served the City from 1958 until 1972. HISTO�HRVATION BOA_nn: At the meeting Of May 23, 1990, the Historic Preservation Board unanimously adopted Resolution No. 22 recommending designation of this property as a Historic Landmark. REOME RATION/SUNKARY Staff is recommending that the Planning Commission adopted the attached findings and support the request. Attachments: 1. Findings 2. Exhibits 3. Resolution No. 22 Submitted by: r7u'! Gloria M. Sciara, Planner I Approved by: Steve Piasecki -,f Planning Director FINDINGS FOR APPROVAL FOR FILE No. ZC 90-05 (HPB 90-03) SITE ADDRESS: 76 ALICE AVENUE APPLICANT: CITY OF CAMPBELL PC NTG DATE: 7/10/90 1. This residential structure is representative of the historic character of the Alice Avenue Historic District. 2. The building is in good condition and has not been altered significantly. 3. Designation of this structure as a landmark will o:sphasize the importance of the Alice Avenue Historic District to the RESOLUTION NO. 22 HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD CITY OF CAMPBELL, CALIFORNIA After notification and public hearing as specified by law on the application filed by Mr. and Mrs. George Maxwell for designation of their residential property at 76 Alice Avenue, in an R-1-H (Single Family/Historic Overlay) Zoning District, as an historic landmark in the City of Campbell, and after testimony by proponents and opponents the hearing was closed. HPB 90-03. After due consideration of all evidence presented, the Historic Preservation Board did find as follows: 1. This residential structure is representative of the historic character of the Alice Avenue Historic District. 2. The building is in good condition and has not been altered significantly. 3. Designation of this structure as a landmark will emphasize the importance of the Alice Avenue Historic District to the Community. Based on the above findings, the Historic Preservation Board does hereby recommend that the Planning Commission and the City Council take action to designate the property at 76 Alice Avenue, Campbell as an Historic Landmark in the City of Campbell, California. PASSED AND ADOPTED this 23rd day of May, 1990, by the following roll call vote: AYES: Boardmembers: Gass, Johnson, King, Burns, Herz NOES: Boardmembers: None ABSENT: Boardmembers: None APPROVED Joanna Herz, Chairperson ATTEST: Phil Stafford Principal Planner CITY OF CAMPBELL 70 NORTH FIRST STREET CAMPBELL, CALIFORNIA 95008 (408) 866-2100 �� r FAX • ( 4 0 8 ) 3 7 9 - 2 5 7 2 1 Planning June 28, 1990 DapartmeM: NOTICE OF HEARING Notice is hereby given that the Planning Commission of the City of Campbell has set the time of 7:30 p.m., or shortly thereafter, on Tuesday, July 10, 1990, in the City Hall Council Chambers, 70 North First Street, Campbell, California, for public hearing to consider the City -initiated application, for a Zone Change to designate property at 76 Alice Avenue, as an Historic Landmark in the City of Campbell. APN: 413-04-061. File No. ZC 90-05 (HPB 90-03). A Negative Declaration has been prepared for this project, pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act. A Negative Declaration has been prepared for this project. Plans, elevations, legal descriptions, and/or other supporting documentation is on file in the Planning Department, 70 North First Street, Campbell, California. Interested persons may appear and be heard at this hearing. Please be advised that if you challenge the nature of the above project in court, you may be limited to raising only those issues you or someone else raised at the public hearing described in this Notice, or in written correspondence delivered to the City of Campbell Planning Commission at, or prior to, the public hearing. Questions may be addressed to the Planning Office at 866-2140. PLANNING COMMISSION CITY OF CAMPBELL STEVE PIASECKI SECRETARY PLEASE NOTE: When calling about this Notice, please, refer to File f ZC 90-05 - Address: 76 Alice Avenue. 76 Alias Avenue Campbell CA 95008 APN: 412-34-005, 6 ZC 90-05 HPB 90-03 PC: 7-10-90 APN: 412-05-080 Rose Schroeder APN: 412-04-048 APN: 412-04-042 128 E Rincon Avenue Harry Smith 33 Sunnyside Avenue Olga Duncan 115 Sunnyside Avenue Campbell CA 95008 Campbell CA 95008 Campbell CA 95008 APN: 412-05-079 Phillip & Merlyn Chan APN: 412-04-047 Elizabeth Szucs APN: 412-04-041 1116 Mill Brae Avenue 12701 Saratoga Avenue Freeman Thompson 131 Sunnyside Avenue Milbrae CA 94030 Saratoga CA 95070 Campbell CA 95008 APN: 412-04-040 Campbell Baptist Church APN: 412-04-046 Roger Thibodeau APN: 412-04-052 151 Sunnyside Avenue 199 Sunnyside Av Scott Brooks. 20 Alice Avenue Cmapbell CA 95008 Campbell CA 95008 Campbell CA 95008 APN: 4120-04-024 Richard Henderson -Gregg APN: 412-04-045 Etta Humphreys APN: 412-04-053 132 Sunnyside Avenue Campbell CA 95008 67 Sunnyside Avenue Judith Neil 30 Alice Avenue Campbell CA 95008 Campbell CA 95009 APN: 412-04-023 Arlette Crews ET AL APN: 412-04-044 Lawrence Ng APN: 412-04-054 199 Sunnyside Avenue Campbell CA 95003 46205 Sentinel Drive Anna Miller 38 Alice Avenue Fremont CA 94538 Campbell CA 95008 APN: 412-04-022 Angelina D'innocenti APN: 412-04-020 APN: 412-04-055 5508 Woodforest Drive Ann Butera 1493 Cherry Avenue Nancy Camp 50 Alice Avenue Sacramento CA 95842 San Jose CA 95125 Campbell CA 95008 APN: 412-04-021 Thelma Miller APN: 412-04-018, 19 APN: 412-04-056 92 Sunnyside Avenue Larry Hester 14089 Apricot Hill Robert Agostinho Campbell CA 95008 Saratoga CA 95070 3555 Parkland Avenue San Jose CA 95117 APN: 412-04-051 Marianne Nelson APN: 412-04-016, 17 APN: 412-05-063 245 Alviso St Gene Mur by p 9525 Heppner Lane Bert Legg 81 Alice Avenue Santa Clara CA 95050 San Jose CA 95136 Campbell CA 95008 APN: 412-04-050 Frank Youngblood APN: 412-04-004 APN: 412-05-075 1156 Steinway Avenue Earl Doise 15050 Mc Vey Avenue Taro Ota 76 East Rincon Avenue Campbell CA 95008 San Jose CA 95127 Campbell CA 95008 APN: 412-04-049 APN: 412-04-043 Samuel Ziegler Tom Powell 1509 Skycrest Drive 105 Sunnyside Avenue Walnut Creek CA 94595 Campbell CA 95008 APN: 412-04-057 APN: 412-0 S GEORGE a DOROTHY MAXWELL -064 APN: 412-05-076 76 ALICE AV PETER a I YERKOVICHSHIRLEYMASON CAMPBELL CA 95008 69 ALICE AVV 88 E E RIAV CAMPBELL CA 95008 C CAMPBELLBELL CA 95008 APN: 412-04-058 BRUCE BARBARA JOHNSON APN: -D APN: 412-05- 80 ALICE AV RAY SPAFFOFFOR DAVID C`IIAPPE ET AL CAMPBELL CA 950008 59 ALICE AV 96 E RINCON AV CAMPBELL CA 95008 CAMPBELL CA 95008 APN: 412-04-059 AUDREY KUNKLE APN: 412-05-06G PATRICK FITZGERALD APN: 412-05-078 R 86 ALICE AV 51 ALICE AV RUGGIERIET AL CAMPBELL CA 95008 CAMPBELL CA 95008 106 E RINCON AV CAMPBELL CA 95008 APN: 412-04-060 FRANK & JANET RAMIREZ APN: 412-05-067 116 ALICE AV CONTE LO ET AL CAMPBELL CA 95008 35 ALICE AV CAMPBELL CA 95008 APN: 412-04-061 MONTE SMITH ET AL APN: 412-05-068 136 ALICE AV FREDERICK A MARY GRANGER CAMPBELL CA 95008 21 ALICE AV CAMPBELL CA 95008 APN: 412-04-062 JOSEPHINE REDLACK APN: 412-05-070 ENIE & FAYE ALKIN 146 ALICE AV 1438 CURTISS AV CAMPBELL CA 95008 SAN JOSE CA 95125 APN: 412-04-063 TERRY BACHELDER ET AL APN: 412-05-071 BANK OF AMERICA NT 150 ALICE AV a SA 4250 WILLIAMS RD CAMPBELL CA 95008 SAN JOSE CA 95129 APN: 412-05-060 NADINE BABB APN: 412-05-072 FLOY MC NEAL ET AL 133 ALICE AV CAMPBELL CA 95008 1642 ELDERBERRY WAY SAN JOSE CA 95125 APN: 412-05-061 J a KAY ATKINSON APN: 412-05-073 RICHARD & REBECCA SMITH 119 ALICE AV P O BOX 700464 CAMPBELL CA 95008 SAN JOSE CA 95170 APN: 412-05-062 JEANETTE GRIZZLE APN: 412-05-074 RICHARD a REBECCA SMITH 99 ALICE AV 4929 PASEO OLIVOS CAMPBELL CA 95008 SAN JOSE CA 95130 San Mercurg Xc Js 750 RIDDER PARK DRIVE SAN JOSE, CALIFORNIA 95190 IN THE CITY OF C WBELL STATE OF CAUFORNIA COUNTY OF SANTA CLARA City of. Camp beIj..................... 75 North G?SiSx§._AY.CI4HR ............... _&AWRk%UA...&A_....2,5.M............................. _I .................... __.._.. NOTICE OF HEARINGS (627 lE%) ....._.._........._..__..—..._... No............_ ..................._....._.___.._....... STATE OF CALIFORNIA, COUNTY OF SANTA CLARA U. I.IIn• 1.tw vwa0*—Mam— ww Yy. TMI.1 aIMr IWMlwllw nWWwbO I" I" .II. ..• aw Y• wiii- a w t"W tI.I—w.Y. a.�M..n y—,"_. wly1•IIw=. .b.l. wM•Y. P«'•.Wp; •rI. w..I wW .r•+9 M ..W 1•n•• w,..1. 11 IN, P•wVn _. a w PMw wq PJwwlw a Yb i.n Jor M.—Y nw . M 7w a Q_.l waA.Ibn PMM"poOWb..•+y M w ay M i.n J..• M ..a Ogewy •I BM.• cW8. SI61• of Gnaw. Ybl MW 5•n A— Mwcwy nww 11 wq H. a Y ` w Mwn qw._ . MN _ a W ... nla..n.n .. — — Y .•Iry. W s__ .00D wa •wb�•w� a w Gw..Il.n o ra.• q iM 6uI. a r�•bv..lyl. •+ Pod•. W MN wnlblb. Y o..•w+• b w II—_ a Ybl s .•YWwlye Iww9 wW Mw.pwK• q . perww c1u�«Iw. N+•q • •ar. •a• YAMplwl M a P.JMV wMnbn, wd Y na OM.IaI to Iti Mw•n• v Vd..•w,i b w w..nwl..wll a •W11/M1 a . P_ 0I K Pa. k ✓.W, fJMp. M I•p P ew.Yni1•Iio� a 4 w •a•r.wnl�r .ro M.Ms a w./.••Ia wan a.ww. P.I•Wvr•Y. I I" W.ry1. q aMr.rrlbr; Pn .1 .1 IbW ..111In•�.Ow — Nb II—•n•awW. OIM•. •n. PIaW. w .•kI my cd a 6w+ Jo.. M W. Cvwny w Sin• M �r ..w..Y b rllw wn ar y.w D PK•IM bn Ptlf Inn a IP• rolk• I h IIbM1a�M. wl Ya mY1 w W M lyp li•I .rrr4 wn rorp.r.f wd .•. Pw:.W..An vaa I•+M era.l«. lyo• nd wlb.w .M naipw.. ww.•IY•V .M ..W ." M Wm Iwln._ IM Wo wd My«Iw a w nab &W*W M M 0.. 11W .b aovMp a . . Y wyw.wf Y • Inw —1" upy, w.. VI..w.d wd PMW M .•w ..W p w m IN, 1.•e v e.l- Io•.e: June 27, 1990 ovm$ 0 9. JML diwY & 2rta.ra._..._.__?yly...................--. 1 Go" waw w.•+ a wM wW W. ft"" Y Y -W �_. _...._ .......__ ... .._...... ....... . .inyr Zb a Ii PMI.I a .. I" n... or&mp&ll OF �b• 1. Mww wb ��Y w Ctit•r bl•r� �b1�w��~�•�/M•pl�� b •w.�j. I�iwr = r w —.rn OPwb1 Y wr. " 41 w • wq. •b.• ..w w0YI YY� ♦ • Pv«.• b► �,�nw«, MwRiRYn!••bb��r.M.. J4YI� OYMl./1. fI►fOI. • cin..wYw ++�+b +��• � w a •�'ir,i b �ggwbwb4R� jwyr.w� �0.�•tlw.wMN��MA! �yrr�•bP•% h[ b V 9a—soY— ��'.Y w�p M.w•�. w w•��q =�w w.1. OAftA blw.Yw M w �.wlb .I.• I.Y.. w M p.•� •�w4 w P.>v M• ti.[ rw•t EIIp UI.N�•/ b .I• Ir.w� eIr 11 v I� DD IUL G Icon CITY OF Cyan,. E L LL PUNNING DEPARTMENT Historic Preservation Board Mirutes May 23, 1990 Page 2 Mr. Stafford reviewed the staff report which had been prepared for this application, and noted that the concerns raised by the Board at the last meeting regarding a lawsuit between the applicant and her son and the legality of the subdivision were still unresolved. Staff recommended that this application be withdrawn from the agenda until the pending issues are resolwd. -noticed and brought Once these issues are settled, the application could be re back for the Board's consideration. Boardmembers Gass, Johnson, and King indicated that they did not feel comfortable going ahead with the landmark designation at this time due to the pending litigation and other issues mentioned. Chairperson Hers opened the public hearing and asked if anyone in the audience wished to speak for or against this application. There being no one, the public hearing was closed. Chairperson Herz asked, for the record, if Mr. Tolesano had discussed the issue of landmark designation with the staf. Ms. Coats and Mr. Stafford indicated that he had not. M/S Johnson/Gass: It was moved that the Historic Preservation Board ramove this application from the agenda until such time as the lawsuit and legality of the lot split have been resolved. At that time, the item could be renoticed for hearing before the Board. Passed 5-0-0. 2. HPB 90-05 Public Hearing to consider the application of Mr. and ZC 90-05 Mrs. George Maxwell to have their property located at 76 Alice Avenue designated as an Historic Landmark. Mr. Stafford rev',.ewed the staff report for this application. It was noted that the home is loc-,.ted in the Alice Avenue Historic Zoning District, and that the current application is for designation of the property as a local historic landmark. Chairperson Herz declared the public hearing open, and asked if anyone in the audience wished to speak for or against this application. There being no one, the public hearing was closed. M/S Johnson/Gass: It was moved that the Historic Preservation Board adopt Resolution No. 22, recommendiig that the Planning Commission and the City Council take the steps necessary to designate the property at 76 Alice Avenue as an Historic Landmark in the City of Campbell. Passed 5-0-0. MISCELLANEOUS: Chairperson Herz indicated that the date for the next study session has not been set at this time, and that she would let staff know once a date has been set. Historic Preservation Board Minutes May 23. 1990 Page 3 ADJOURNK MT: On the notion of Boardmember King, seconded by Boardmamber Burns, the Historic Preservation Board sleeting of May 23, 1990- at 5:40 P.M. to the next regular Historic Preservation Board Meeting of June 27. 1990. at 5:00 P.m., in the City Council Chambers, 70 North First Street, Campbell. APPROVED: Joanna Herz Chairperson ATTEST: Phil Stafford Principal Planner RECORDED BY: Pat Masters Recording Secretary Ah Ah ITEM N0. STAFF REPORT - HISTORIC PRESERVATION MEETING OF MAY 23. 1990 HP1 90-03 Public Hearing to consider the application of Mr. and Mrs. George ZC90-05 Maxwell to have their property located ALt 76 Alice Avenue, Marnll,G. is an 1-1-H (Single Family Resida tial/distoric) Zoning District, designated as an Historic Landmark. STAFF RECOMMENDATION That the Historic Preservation Board adopt a resolution incorporating the attached findings, recommanding that the City Council designate the Saunders -Maxwell House at 76 Alice Avenue as an historic landmark, STAFF DISCUSSION: The property owners of the residential property located at 76 Alice Avenue have submitted a request to have their property designated as an Historic Landmark in the City of Campbell. The property is located in the Alice Avenue Historic District. PROJECT SITE: The site is currently developed with a one story wood frame house with a stucco finish. The house has a hip roof with wood shingles and a gable in the front. The estimated date for construction of the residence is 1922. HISTORIC SIGNIFICANCE: Alice Avenue was created in 1915, on a portion of the site of the fruit drying yards owned by the George E. Hyde Company. The residential subdivision was called the Hyde Residential Park, after George and Alice Hyde. The property was owned by Mr. Lee Saunders, an early weighmaster and receiving foreman for the J.C. Ainsley Company. In 1958, the property was acquired by Mr. George Maxwell. Mr. Maxwell was the first full-time Fire Chief for the City of Campbell and served the City from 1958 to 1792. MPH 90-03 ZC 90-05 Maxwell, G. REC0MMENDED FINDINGS FOR APPROVAL: I. This residential structure is representative of the historic character of the Alice Avenue Historic District. 2. The building is is good condition and has not been altered significantly. 3. Designation of this structure as a landmark will amhasise the importance of the Alice Avenue Historic District to the casmaanity. RIS'bORIC PRZSZRVATION BoaRD cIW Or CAMPBZLL, CALIFUNrIA 5:00 P.M. WEDNESDAY CITY HALL, COUNCIL CHAMBERS APRIL 25, 1990 HIROrRs The Historic Preservation Board of the City of Campbell convened this day in regular session in the City Hall Council Chambers, 70 North First Street, Campbell, California. ROLL CALL Boardmembers Present: Chairperson Harz Ruth Gass Barbara Johnson Jack Burns Sue King Boardmembers Absent: None Staff Present: Phil Stafford, Principal Planner Peggy Coats, Museum Director Pat Masters, Recording Secretary APPffiAL OF THE JEENUTES HIS Gass/Johnson Motion to approve the Minutes of March 28, 1990, was unanimously approved, as submitted. casmu dgations None Public Hearings 1. HPB 90-02 Continued Public Hearing to consider the applica- ZC 90-02 tion of Mrs. Louise Steele for designation of the Steele, L. residence located on property known as 1228 Harriet Ave., in an R-1-9 (Single -Family Residential) Zoning District as an Historic Landmark. Staff Presentation Mr. Stafford called attention to the following: City Attorney advised, based on information provided by applicant, enough information was available to proceed with application. Boardmember Johnson expressed the concern of the other boardmembers that they felt they had continued this hearing from previous meetings because of earthquake damage, and the Building Department had recommended doing nothing until the repairs have been made. Historic Preservation Board Minutes April 25, 1990 Page 2 Public Hearing ZC 90-02 (Con-t.) Mr. Stafford brought their attention to Condition of Approval 11 wherein no permits would be issued by the Building Department until applicant satisfied all their requirements. He also reported that after speaking to applicant, the engineer's report is not completed at this time. There was no urgency in this matter, and if the Board wished to continue to for one more month, there would be no problem. Public Hearing was opened. Mr. James E. Tolosano, 1222 Harriet Ave., Campbell. Mr. Tolosano, son of the applicant, addressed the Board. He reported that the status of his lawsuit with his mother could take quite some time and he asked the Board to consider postponing this application for as long as possible. The Board clarified his questions as to what a Historic Landmark actually entails, and its procedures. He was encouraged by Museum director Coats to stop by the Museum where she would c'••e him information which would enable him to better understs.id the procedure. No other speakers were present. Board Discussion; Boardmember King suggested we take matter off calendar until legal matter could be clarified. Mr. Stafford suggested continuing the hearing for one more month which would enable Mr. Tolosan, to bring to the Board any new information on the law suit. Should no resolution take place at the next meeting, he recommended supporting Boardmember King's suggestion to take the mattes off calendar and re -noticed when it became appropriate. HIS Johnson/Gass Motion to continue Public Hearing on HPB 90-02 to the next regular scheduled meeting of the Historic Preservation Board of May 23, 1990. Passed 5-0-0-0. * i i Miscellaneous 1. Santa Clara County Chairperson Herz reported the Santa Clara County Board of Supervisors gave $300,000 to Campbell to assist in the move of the Ainsley house to its new location, which would become the Museum. She also reported that careful consideration would be given to the house -movers, so that no damage would be caused. Historic Preserv-tion Board Minutes April 25, 1990 Page 3 Miscellaneous - (Con-t.) 2. Museum Vice Chairperson Johnson reported on the Campbell Historic Museum Association. She noted there was a lot of non visual activity taking place, more of a "housecleaning" nature to get ready for the commitment they will be facing, once the Ainsley house is moved. Reorganizing/restructuring board committees, restrPhaseuItandnwill bewaddressingpecial Councilund andraiser Board on1ll Mayi8th to give report, which will be a preliminary study. She also reported the new Controller is Jane Meyer. History of Campbell Book. Should be ready from printer sometime in late June or early July. In a previews meeting, it had been suggested that reports from both of the above Boards be sent to the other. Vice Chairperson Johnson reported this had now been *tone. 3. Chairperson Herz reported on the Mayor's Roundtable M.+eting. 4. s�dv Se=sion Next Study Session would be scheduled for May 23, 1990, at 3:30 in the Ralph Doetsch Conference Room, City Hall. dQJOORNMBNT On motion of Boardmember King, seconded by Boardmember Johnson, the Historic Preservation Board meeting of April 25, 1990, adjourned at 6:00 p.m. to the next regular Historic Preservation Board meeting of May 23, 1990, at 5:00 p.m., in the City Council Chambers, 70 North First Street, Campbell. APPROVED: Joanna Her Chairperson ATTEST: _ Phil Stafford Principal Planner RECORDED BY: Pat Mast rs _ Reporting Secretary .Err,PR., S:rcn/ FOTICE OF NEMNO ce is hereby given that Historic Preservation Board of the City of Campbell has set 6:00 pso. on Wednesday May 23, 1060, In the Council Chem, bars, Campbell City Hall, 70 North First Street, Comp. bell, California. .- "A time and place f.-r ► public hearing to consider the aPPllcation of Mr. and Mrs. George Maxwell to hsr; theirproperty loci :a at 76 Alice Avenue deagnated as an Historic Landmark. (HPB 00.03, A.P.N. 413-"1) PLANNING COMMISSION CITY OF CAMPBELL STEVE PIASECKI, SECRETARY 016404 CiTY OF CAMPBELL, CALIFORNIA REQUEST TO HAVE THE HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD SET PUBLIC HEARING TO CONSIDER DESIGNATION OF AN HISTORIC LANDMARK 1. APPLICANT: NAME Cc" , RI 4jjDATE 7 -jjv ADDRESS /a e - )4 L' n l.s /( C' ei +oe S TELyos _a-zA +�A 31 2. PROPERTY: ADDRESS ,�, d•, a1"' ' ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER y- (� / 3. PROPERTY OWNER: NAME (if not applicant) ADDRESS TEL. 4. LEGAL DESCRIPTION: Applicant must file a current legal description of the proposed landmark's location. 5. MAP: Applicant must submit a location map of the property proposed for landmark designation. 6. DESCRIPTION: A. Applicant must submit information at the time of filing, Aescribing the proposed landmark's special aesthetic, cultural, architectural, or engineering interest or value of an historic nature. B. Applicant must submit sketches, drawings, photographs, 1 or other descriptive materials which will aid the Historic Preservation Board in determining the proposed landmarks historic value. 1. FEE: None CERTIFICATE OF APPLICANT: 1/1-le the undersigned have some direct or indirect interest in the property described above, and in the proposed historic landmark. It is understood that such a request is made without the necessity that the Historic preservation Board grant the request. The information contained herein is true and correct to sly (our) best.knowledge and belief. / ) feir Signature(s) of rso s ng Request L l_tcj�f DATE: Signa ures o per y r s State of Cal-tol ii, Ti,. R.— DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION ..c.. No. UTMA HgBS__ HAER_ NR SHL : Loc HISTORIC RESOURCES INVENTORY — e C D IDENTIFICATION I. Co"..., .me. Saunders -Maxwell House I. Historic rwme, none known 3. Street or rural aldress: 76 Alice Avenue City raernhPl j Zip-95008 County Santa Clara 4. Parcel number: 413-4-61 5. Present Owner. renrdP R. MawwPl l Address. 76 Alice Avenue City - CamnhPll Zip 95008 (fnershipis'Public private xx 6. Present Uw: residence Original use: residence DESCRIPTION I'a. Architectural style. Provincial Period Revival (c.1920-41) 7b. Briefly describe the prawns physrba/daonprron of the site or structure and describe any major alterations from its original condition: One story wood frame house, finished with stucco; wood shingled hipped roof with front gable. Triple casement type windows with square paned glass in front gable; three rectangular sash -hung windows in northwest front facade. 8. Construction date: 1922 Estimated xx Factual 9. Architect unknown 10. Builder Andy Johnson 11. Approx. propany sin (in noel) Frontage go Depth lrQ or approx. acreage 12. Datelsl of sndord photowsphld October 1985 r 13. Condition: Excellent - Good AS Fair _ Deteriorated _ No longer in existence 14. Altarahons: added barn• wall remev d in dining roo� (Chock more than onal ,, necessary) Ili- Residential JSx IMwtr,al Open land _ Scattered buildings _ D,..c.;y coil[ -up __ Clwaaa "_._._ Other: —, It Threats to site: None known _ltrkVW deealopment _ Zoning_- Vandalwn Public Works protect Otter: — -- 17 Is the strupure: On its original ella2_ Movedi Unknown) ---_ 18. Related features: SIGNIFICANCE 10. Briefly state historical and/or architectural importance (include dates, events, and arsons associated with the site.) Alice Avenue was created in 1915 on a portion of the site of the fruit drying yards owned by George E. Hyde Company, a canning and fruit dehydrating plant occupying 17 acres in Campbell. The land was originally owned and utilized by Fleming's Fruit Oryer (1887); sold to Frank Buxton's Dryer (1890) and again sold to Campbell Fruit Grower's Union (1892) which owned and controlled the drying yards and packing house until its sale to George Hyde in 1909. The residential subdivision "Hyde Residential Park" although George and Alice Hyde (the street's namesake) resided there too. Lee Saunders was an early weighmaster and receiving foreman for J.C. Ainsley Packing Company, Campbell. G% Maxwell purchased the house in 1953. Maxwell was the first full-time fire chin Campbell, replacing volunteer chief, Jack Scott, and serving from 1958 to 1972. 20. Main theme of the historic resource: (If more than one is chocked, number in order of importance.) Architecture Arts d Leisure Economic/IndustrusIX& Exploration/Settlement _ Government Military Religion Sows/Education _ 21. Sources (List books, documents, surveys• personal interviews and their dates). 8 Oct 1977: Interview by Barbara Klein with owner, George Maxwell 1977-78 Survey 22. Data form prepared %'t..! /914 ey(nome) Pegg 'V fonts Organization f/t� of fxmnhnll Address: 7n N Circt Ctrnnt cityfA.Phpll _Zip gSnnR Phone: (VIA) Af.F_711A Initial survey notes were taken by Barbara Klein, 1564 Keesling, San Jose, 8 Oct 1977. Local.onal sketch map (draw and label site and wrroundlr,g streats, roads, and prominent landmarks). NORTH ALICE z �n . e 1. ore i 2 t^ n L 4 5 6V iy rr. ra i f ax Sin UNNv51DE 76 Alice Avenue A MEMORANDUM CITY OF CAMPBELL I To: Peggy Coats March 22, 1990 Museum Director Date: Date: From: Tim J. Haley �"- Planner II Subp": Historic Landmark Application No. HPB 90-03 - 76 Alice Avenue Please find attached an application form for the consideration of 76 Alice Avenue as an Historic Landmark. If you feel a new form should be completed or if additional information is necessary, please contact the Maxwells. Once you have had a chance to review this request and its completeness, please forward a copy to the Planning Dnpartment so that it may be agendized for a future Historic Preservation Board meeting. cc: Phil Stafford T '%0 ks Al APR 10 1990 CITY OF L-- -:! L y}/ (/ sµ;rr PUNNING DEP^W pa..r a/IY I�